Part 0 (live): flash apps on 9201 were down due to an operator pct reboot at
10:26 UTC + a boot-ordering race — dockerd auto-starts unless-stopped flash apps
~18s before the agent re-binds felhom-flash, so the create-time bind mkdir fails
(permission denied) and RestartCount=0 never retries. Drive healthy, data intact,
no USB drop, durable-id fine, drive-gate uninvolved. v0.70.0 self-restart RULED
OUT (container restart, not a guest reboot; +38min after exits). Fix: restarted
the 7 apps via the controller (drive present) — all Up. Flagged the intermediary
mount app-start race as an architectural gap.
Parts 1-3 (cited): characterized escrow (K + identity under recovery code R,
fingerprint-gated, hub zero-knowledge) + PBS whole-CT contents (rootfs/secrets in,
external drives out) + capstone DONE vs PENDING (agent-side recovery orchestration
not wired, syncer.go:92). Defined the secret-free DR recipe (guest sizing + drive
durable-id/role inventory + PVE storage + app bindings + PBS coords), sourced from
facts the agent/controller already hold, landing in the reserved
WireDesiredState.storage_manifest placeholder. Field-by-field boundary proof + a
no-secrets test spec. Fork list + recommendation: spec/emit/store the recipe now,
defer re-enrollment auth to slice 10D, never touch the escrow/PBS secret path.
No code changes, no version bump.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Report-only audit. Confirms the infra-backup push died at slice 8C
(controller v0.37.0) — builder deleted, PushInfraBackup +
NotifyBackupCompleted left as caller-less stubs; agent never
re-implemented it. Same root cause as the daily deadline-check email
(no backup_completed emitter). Live hub records inspected read-only:
plaintext secrets at rest (AES master key + restic pw + Cloudflare
tokens) = zero-knowledge violation; disk_layout is bare-metal-era.
Recommends phased retire-now / revive-concept-later (secret-free DR
recipe) + fork list. No code changes.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Live-validated on demo guest 9201 (felhom-flash throwaway): shared/slave mount
propagation delivers host->guest drive swaps live with no restart and no pct
change; bind source = permanent stable dir => inherently C1-immune (clean boot
with drive absent). nsenter fallback non-viable on unprivileged LXC; ro-tmpfs
placeholder is the CAP_DAC_OVERRIDE-proof fail-close. Report-only, no code change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Live unattended UI exercise of migration/decommission/re-enroll/eject +
feature sweep on shipped controller v0.66.2 / agent v0.32.0 (guest 9201).
No production code changed.
Migration engine solid (all moves checksum-verified identical, sources
cleaned, HDD_PATH flipped, apps healthy). Lifecycle gaps found:
- C1 (critical): decommission/eject leave a stale LXC mp (no pct delete)
-> guest fails pre-start hook on next reboot, ALL apps down. Recovered
live via pct set --delete mp1.
- H1: /api/storage/{disconnect,reconnect,restart-apps} are 404 (unrouted)
though settings.js calls them.
- H2: no UI button for /api/storage/decommission.
- H3: no one-click re-enroll for a decommissioned drive.
- M1: decommissioning the default drive doesn't reassign the default.
- M2: eject does NOT auto-remount (intent-gated like decommission).
- M3: userdata/import/calibre created 755 at enroll; migrate-all doesn't
re-assert setgid on pre-existing dirs (16/17 preserved 2775).
- M4: felhom-usb mount unit had stale UUID; M6: test-email fails (no SMTP).
End-state sane: apps healthy on felhom-flash (now default), both data
drives Aktiv, reboot-safe, sda/PBS/controller untouched.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Report-only spike + one live throwaway FORMAT experiment on /dev/sdc.
No production code, no version bump.
- Q1: raw-disk discovery gap confirmed — Observe AND localapi GET /disks
are both built only from PVE storages (ListStorage/NodeStorage); a
not-yet-storage disk is invisible. proxmox client has no /disks/* method.
- Q3: safety classifier (RoleForRawDevice/SystemDisks/RoleForStorage)
already protects sda/felhom-pbs live, but needs two hardening checks:
whole-disk-granularity enrolled-subtraction + LVM-PV membership.
- Q6: FORMAT path proven end-to-end live — pvesh disks/directory create
-> agent Observe -> controller "Regisztralas" enroll. sdc left as the
clean enrolled felhom-flash B3 migration target. sda/sdb untouched.
- Premise correction: felhom-pbs is remote (no local PBS disk).
- Fork list for the build spec in the audit doc + REPORT.md.
Maps current namespace dir creation/ownership (live on 9201), the 9-app/13-mount
media blast radius, run-identity table (FileBrowser=uid1000, komga/audiobookshelf=root),
LXC idmap, and proposes the setgid GID-1000 convention. Flags: MigrateAll's merge walk
drops setgid+owner on userdata. Ends with a 7-item fork list. No code/deploy.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Relocates the 2026-06-14 live-drive findings + fixspec from the felhom-controller
repo root into documentation/audits/ (alongside the bughunt-reconcile/deep-sweep
records), and preserves the M18/M19 implementable fix-plans (from the deleted
controller fix/m18 + fix/m19 branches) into a new documentation/backlog/. Part of
the trunk-based no-branches reconciliation.
Brings the 2026-06-13 audit + reconciliation under documentation/audits/ with
per-finding remediation status (controller v0.59.0 fixes deployed to demo;
AGENT-001 fix prepared/pending review).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
admin