admin
314308b4aa
The operator ruled D1-D6 as recommended. Build A shipped (agent v0.157.0, controller v0.317.0 MinAgent 0.157.0, hub v0.154.0): live on Tester 1 (unknown/vm, the "cannot check" notice, copies made not counted), demo-hp and the N100 (proven, different, unchanged). NAS notice and the no-drive sentence are unit-proven only. STATUS: D10 removed; vouch agent 0.157.0 and rule on R-1082 added. Poster: the Tier-2 line, text only. Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_012qRErfCoiTkvDK9N5XHbzb
Storage identity, build A — live evidence (2026-10-15)
Design: architecture/16-storage-physical-identity.md (§13 = what was built). Releases: agent v0.157.0 (not vouched),
controller v0.317.0 (MinAgent 0.157.0), hub v0.154.0. Rows: R-1072, R-1074, R-1075 closed; R-1068, R-1079 narrowed;
R-1082, R-1083, R-1084 opened.
Method: endpoint level — no browser on DooPlex. The agent's local API on each PVE host (the same calls the controller makes, with the guest's own token), the dashboard pages and the „run Tier-2 now" endpoint the buttons call, and the hub's database copied with its WAL (a different channel from the agent calls). Times are UTC.
The boxes
| Box | What it is | Agent says | Household sees on /backups |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tester 1 | Felhom inside a VM on demo-hp | every place unknown/vm; drive vs system data: not proven (vm) |
„A Felhom nem tudja ellenőrizni, hogy a második meghajtó valóban másik lemez-e … ezért nem számolja második másolatnak.” A Tier-2 run copied 10 apps; each app row on /backups/apps says „…ezt a másolatot nem számolja második másolatnak” |
| demo-hp | HP t740, SATA SSD + NVMe | every place proven; drive vs system data: different, proven |
no one-copy notice; Tier-2 copied 10 apps, counted (unchanged) |
| N100 | SATA SSD + USB disk (the bridge passes the real serial) | every place proven; drive vs system data: different, proven |
no one-copy notice; Tier-2 copied 5 apps, counted (unchanged) |
All three, same-disk call: system data vs /var/lib/docker → same disk, proven; a drive name that is not mounted →
unmapped (never „the system disk").
Search controls (Hungarian searched with ASCII fragments nem tudja / nem sz): Tester 1 after → 11 hits (positive:
the notice + 10 app lines). demo-hp → 0. N100 → 1 hit, read by eye: „…külön adatbázis-kiírás nem szükséges” — not the
notice (negative holds).
Files
| File | What |
|---|---|
agent-disks-{demo-hp,n100,tester1}.json |
the agent's GET /disks with the new fields |
agent-same-disk-live.txt |
POST /disks/same-disk — three pairs per box |
tester1-rc1.txt |
Tester 1 on 0.317.0-rc.1 by hand (first look) |
tester1-tier2-run.txt, tester1-tier2-log.txt |
the Tier-2 run on rc.1 and its log (unproven copies) |
tester1-backup-pages.txt |
/backups + /backups/apps on rc.1 |
per-customer-floors.txt |
per-box floors 0.317.0 / MinAgent 0.157.0 for tester-1, demo-hp, demo-felhom — 303 floor_set at 19:27:52 |
demo-hp-backup-page.txt, n100-backup-page.txt |
the pages before the Tier-2 runs |
{demo-hp,n100}-tier2-run.txt, -tier2-log.txt |
Tier-2 runs on 0.317.0 (counted copies) |
{demo-hp,n100,tester1}-backup-pages-after.txt |
the pages after, all on 0.317.0 |
hub-stored-identity.txt |
the hub's latest stored report per box: kind, identity, reason, physical disks |
9202-before-0.314.0.txt, 9202-after-0.317.0.txt, 9202-upgrade.txt |
the NAS check on the scratch box: it has no local_api, so it cannot ask the agent (R-1083); put back on 0.314.0 at 19:40:35 |
Not shown live (unit-proven, red-proved)
- A same-disk Tier-2 target skipped — no box has two places on one disk.
- A NAS share does not hide the one-copy notice (R-1075) — 9202 cannot reach its agent (R-1083).
- The no-drive install sentence „Ehhez az alkalmazáshoz egy adattároló kell. A Meghajtók oldalon adhatsz hozzá egyet.”
— no one-disk box at hand (R-1068). Deliberately not probed with a deploy request (
live-probes.md). usb_bridge— no such device seen.
Also seen
- Tester 1's page also says „Ezt a meghajtót kijelölheted a rendszermentés helyéül — így egy lemezhiba után is vissza tudod állítani a rendszert.” The whole-box backup offer does not ask about identity → R-1084.
- R-1072 is closed entirely:
backup.target.degradedwas already informal, and the formal wordcsatlakoztassonis gone from all three pages (0 hits each; 1 hit on the OMV run's pageomv-vm-2026-10-15/B4-backup-pages.txt, the control).
Teardown
Machine: Tester 1, demo-hp 9201, N100 9201 stay on 0.317.0 through their per-box floors (cleared after the global floor);
9202 back on 0.314.0. Host: the helper script /tmp/agentq.sh removed from demo-hp, felhom-pve and Tester 1's host.
Hub: three per-customer floors set (listed above); nothing else. No app installed or removed; no disk touched.