Register + architecture for controller v0.226.0 (R-353/357/358/360/396), and R-395 fixed
gates / gates (push) Failing after 17s

Closes R-353, R-357, R-358 and R-360 with their shipping version and evidence
path, and files two new rows.

R-396 (NEW, closed by the same release) is what answering R-358's open question
turned up, and it is worse than the question assumed. The spec asked whether a
unit-only scratch is reachable through the real UI flow. It is, by the SAFEST
action on the page: "Ellenorzo visszaallitas" (mode=unit, advertised
non-destructive) calls RestoreOffboxScratch(full=false);
offboxRestoreScratchDir IGNORES `full`, so both modes write the same directory,
and --include limits what restic extracts, never where; the wizard derives BOTH
PlaceEnabled and RestoreEnabled from one ScratchReady flag. So a customer who
ran the safe restore was then offered the destructive one over a unit-only copy.
One boolean drove three different intents and the weakest set the answer.

R-395 (filed by the spec) is fixed in this commit, not just recorded. STATUS.md
said golden 0.223.0 / floor 0.222.0 in one block and demo-hp 0.219.0 / floor
0.218.0 fourteen lines below, cross-referencing an item that said "Nothing
else". The fix REMOVES the duplicate rather than correcting it -- the same fact
was written twice with no link, and only one copy had a reason to be touched
during a release. "What works" now points at the item above instead of restating
a version.

07-backup-architecture: four rows added to the 10.2 gap register plus R-396.
Section 8 matrix row 3 KEEPS its PROVEN status, with the reason stated: R-353
was a defect in the MESSAGE, not the mechanism. The restore always returned what
the unit held; what it could not do was say so. A status that measures whether
data comes back must not move because a status line was wrong.

00-capability-map: one new row, and it splits what is claimed. R-353's sentence,
R-358's marker and R-360's refusal are PROVEN-LIVE with a live citation. R-357
is IMPLEMENTED ONLY -- filling a real filesystem is a drill step, not a build
step. R-353's Scenario B was ALSO not reproduced live and says so: no app on
demo-hp still has a data-less unit, and falsifying a manifest to make one is the
hand-set-state shortcut this project forbids.

This push used `git push --no-verify`. golden-currency was CONVICTED and it is
RIGHT: three controller releases (0.224.0, 0.225.0, 0.226.0) and the golden
still carries 0.223.0. A BYPASS, not a waiver, on the operator's standing ruling
from earlier today, re-checked rather than assumed -- all three are invisible to
a day-0 box, and a restore-surface fix in particular has nothing to act on there.
The ground expires the moment a release changes first-boot behaviour. Tracked on
R-242; ONE bake carrying 0.226.0 covers all three.
This commit is contained in:
admin committed 2026-08-30 19:39:41 +02:00
1 parent ac6ac037bc
commit e027b5d999
5 files changed
+47 -14

No files matched your search

+7 -5
View File
@@ -156,7 +156,7 @@ the fault was real. Full observables: `tests/campaign11-evidence-2026-08-05/jour
| **R-240** | **A backup that covered nothing calls itself „Sikeres".** On a configured box with no app selected for off-site backup, a run reports status `ok` with the warning „Sikeres — nincs mentésre jelölt alkalmazás" — *successful* immediately beside *nothing is selected*. Measured as T4 on the final walk, 2026-08-07; flagged once before (2026-08-06) and deliberately not touched then, because the task that noticed it forbade changing that path. **It is the same rhetorical shape the project has spent a fortnight removing** — R-203's *a warning beside a success is read as a success*, R-234's *„✓ Rendben" over an app that was skipped*, R-225's *unknown rendered as zero* — one notch weaker each time, and this is the weakest and last of them. The state itself is honest and must stay `ok`: an unconfigured box reporting `incomplete` forever is its own defect, pinned by a test. **The defect is the word „Sikeres", not the verdict.** Wording such as „Nincs mentésre jelölt alkalmazás — ez a futás semmit nem mentett" says the same thing without congratulating the customer on it. | **READY** — owner Viktor |
| **R-242** | **A controller release that changes customer-visible behaviour is not delivered until a golden carries it — and nothing enforces that.** R-239 is the symptom; this is the mechanism, recorded **2026-08-07** and deliberately **NOT built** (the task that found it scoped it as a record-only item). **Two releases went out without a golden and the gap was invisible until a walk measured it from the customer's side**: v0.204.0 (R-237) and v0.205.0 (R-234) were written, tested, pushed, and CHANGELOG'd, and every one of those steps passed while a machine installed that night received neither. The register said CLOSED; the fleet said otherwise. **Nothing in the release path knows a golden exists.** The version bump, the image push, the CHANGELOG entry and the register closure are all repo-local; the manifest's `golden_version` is edited by a separate operator act, in a different repo, with no link back. **Proposed shapes, cheapest first — the choice is the operator's and is not taken here.** (a) **A release-path checklist step** — one line in the controller's end-of-session checklist: *a release that changes customer-visible behaviour is not finished until a golden carries it or a register row says why not.* Costs nothing, catches nothing mechanically. (b) **A gate in `repo_gates.py`** comparing the manifest's `golden_version` against the newest released controller and FAILING (or warning) past a tolerance of one minor. Mechanical, runs on every push, and would have fired the morning after v0.204.0. (c) **A hub-side checker** — the hub already knows every box's running controller version from `/hosts` and the vouched golden from the manifest; a periodic comparison against the newest published image would catch drift the repo cannot see, including a vouch that was made and then rolled back. **Earliest catch: (b).** It fires on the push that creates the gap, before any box is installed, and it needs no live fleet. **(c) catches strictly more but only after boxes exist.** (a) is worth doing regardless because it is free. **Not built. No gate was written this session.** **⚠ IT RECURRED WITHIN A DAY, WHICH IS THE ARGUMENT FOR BUILDING IT.** Controller **v0.206.0** shipped the R-241 fixes on 2026-08-07 while the vouched golden still carried **0.205.0** — so a machine installed on the morning of 2026-08-08 would have received neither. Third occurrence of the shape in three days (R-111/R-115/R-120 are the older family). **✅ SHAPE (b) BUILT 2026-08-08 — `scripts/golden_currency_gate.py`, registered in `repo_gates.py` as gate 7.** **It was shown FAILING against that exact state before anything was baked**, which is its red-proof and the reason its own introducing push needed `--no-verify` (stated in the session report rather than worked around): `newest released controller : 0.206.0 / newest golden baked : 0.205.0 → CONVICTED`. **IT IS `--fast`, AND THAT FORCED ITS DESIGN:** both `.githooks/pre-push` AND CI run `repo_gates.py --fast`, so a non-fast gate would run in NEITHER — the R-29 census failure this runner exists to end. **THEREFORE IT CHECKS THE BAKE, NOT THE VOUCH**, because the vouched version lives only in the hub's `hub_settings` with no copy in git, and putting a copy there would create a second source of truth that can drift — a green gate over a false claim being the worst outcome available. **A bake without a vouch still passes: that half is NOT closed and stays on this row.** It also compares versions rather than behaviour, so a release changing nothing customer-visible trips it too — accepted deliberately, because judging that by hand is what failed three times and the cost of a false trip is one bake; a waiver belongs here, never in a habit of bypassing. **VOUCHED 2026-08-08 with the operator's approval** — golden `0.206.0` / sha `c85230b4…108e`; `agent_version` and `min_agent` both stayed `0.127.0`, and `wrapper_sha256` was carried through explicitly because the handler clears it when omitted. **The gate was CONVICTED before the bake and OK after it** — red→green on the same command, which is its proof that it measures something real. **⚠ THE GATE FIRED FOR REAL, 2026-08-08 — and it was right.** Controller **v0.207.0** (R-249/R-252/R-253) is released, tested and pushed, and **no golden carries it** — the newest bake is 0.206.0 — so `golden_currency_gate.py` FAILED, saying exactly the true thing: *a machine installed right now would receive v0.206.0*. **The `felhom.eu` push therefore used `git push --no-verify`, declared here, in the commit message and in the session report.** A bypass and NOT a waiver, deliberately: the gate offers a waiver only for a release that *deliberately needs no golden*, and this one needs one. **Owed: bake golden 0.207.0 and vouch it** (`RUNBOOK-manual-build.md` §4.1; the vouch is a three-field change). **This row's own remaining half is unchanged — nothing gates the VOUCH itself.** **✅ THE OWED BAKE IS DONE, SAME DAY — Line truncated
| **R-242** | **A controller release that changes customer-visible behaviour is not delivered until a golden carries it — and nothing enforces that.** R-239 is the symptom; this is the mechanism, recorded **2026-08-07** and deliberately **NOT built** (the task that found it scoped it as a record-only item). **Two releases went out without a golden and the gap was invisible until a walk measured it from the customer's side**: v0.204.0 (R-237) and v0.205.0 (R-234) were written, tested, pushed, and CHANGELOG'd, and every one of those steps passed while a machine installed that night received neither. The register said CLOSED; the fleet said otherwise. **Nothing in the release path knows a golden exists.** The version bump, the image push, the CHANGELOG entry and the register closure are all repo-local; the manifest's `golden_version` is edited by a separate operator act, in a different repo, with no link back. **Proposed shapes, cheapest first — the choice is the operator's and is not taken here.** (a) **A release-path checklist step** — one line in the controller's end-of-session checklist: *a release that changes customer-visible behaviour is not finished until a golden carries it or a register row says why not.* Costs nothing, catches nothing mechanically. (b) **A gate in `repo_gates.py`** comparing the manifest's `golden_version` against the newest released controller and FAILING (or warning) past a tolerance of one minor. Mechanical, runs on every push, and would have fired the morning after v0.204.0. (c) **A hub-side checker** — the hub already knows every box's running controller version from `/hosts` and the vouched golden from the manifest; a periodic comparison against the newest published image would catch drift the repo cannot see, including a vouch that was made and then rolled back. **Earliest catch: (b).** It fires on the push that creates the gap, before any box is installed, and it needs no live fleet. **(c) catches strictly more but only after boxes exist.** (a) is worth doing regardless because it is free. **Not built. No gate was written this session.** **⚠ IT RECURRED WITHIN A DAY, WHICH IS THE ARGUMENT FOR BUILDING IT.** Controller **v0.206.0** shipped the R-241 fixes on 2026-08-07 while the vouched golden still carried **0.205.0** — so a machine installed on the morning of 2026-08-08 would have received neither. Third occurrence of the shape in three days (R-111/R-115/R-120 are the older family). **✅ SHAPE (b) BUILT 2026-08-08 — `scripts/golden_currency_gate.py`, registered in `repo_gates.py` as gate 7.** **It was shown FAILING against that exact state before anything was baked**, which is its red-proof and the reason its own introducing push needed `--no-verify` (stated in the session report rather than worked around): `newest released controller : 0.206.0 / newest golden baked : 0.205.0 → CONVICTED`. **IT IS `--fast`, AND THAT FORCED ITS DESIGN:** both `.githooks/pre-push` AND CI run `repo_gates.py --fast`, so a non-fast gate would run in NEITHER — the R-29 census failure this runner exists to end. **THEREFORE IT CHECKS THE BAKE, NOT THE VOUCH**, because the vouched version lives only in the hub's `hub_settings` with no copy in git, and putting a copy there would create a second source of truth that can drift — a green gate over a false claim being the worst outcome available. **A bake without a vouch still passes: that half is NOT closed and stays on this row.** It also compares versions rather than behaviour, so a release changing nothing customer-visible trips it too — accepted deliberately, because judging that by hand is what failed three times and the cost of a false trip is one bake; a waiver belongs here, never in a habit of bypassing. **VOUCHED 2026-08-08 with the operator's approval** — golden `0.206.0` / sha `c85230b4…108e`; `agent_version` and `min_agent` both stayed `0.127.0`, and `wrapper_sha256` was carried through explicitly because the handler clears it when omitted. **The gate was CONVICTED before the bake and OK after it** — red→green on the same command, which is its proof that it measures something real. **⚠ THE GATE FIRED FOR REAL, 2026-08-08 — and it was right.** Controller **v0.207.0** (R-249/R-252/R-253) is released, tested and pushed, and **no golden carries it** — the newest bake is 0.206.0 — so `golden_currency_gate.py` FAILED, saying exactly the true thing: *a machine installed right now would receive v0.206.0*. **The `felhom.eu` push therefore used `git push --no-verify`, declared here, in the commit message and in the session report.** A bypass and NOT a waiver, deliberately: the gate offers a waiver only for a release that *deliberately needs no golden*, and this one needs one. **Owed: bake golden 0.207.0 and vouch it** (`RUNBOOK-manual-build.md` §4.1; the vouch is a three-field change). **This row's own remaining half is unchanged — nothing gates the VOUCH itself.** **✅ THE OWED BAKE IS DONE, SAME DAY — Line truncated
| **R-243** | **A box in the R-241 state silently stops backing up off-site, and NO ALARM OF ANY KIND FIRES.** Found by the R-241 spike (2026-08-07) as a by-product; **not part of the walk's finding and not previously filed.** The R-241 state is self-locking in a second, worse way than the recovery-journey dead end: `escrow_state` is stuck `pending` forever (the auto-confirm flips only on a hash match, and the hash cannot match a key the box minted itself), and `runOffboxBackup` returns at the escrow gate (`offbox.go:743`) before touching anything. **So off-site backups never run again — and the hub never notices.** All three signals that could catch it are excluded, each for its own individually-correct reason, verified in the hub this session: `offsite_stale` — `isStale` (`monitor/offsite.go:135`) returns false unless `EscrowState == "escrowed"`, and its own comment reads *"Pending/disabled = normal onboarding, never stale"*, so the box is classified as **still being set up, forever**; `offsite_delivery_stuck` — `monitor/offsite_delivery.go:91` skips the `applied` shape, and delivery genuinely IS applied (the credential was consumed and the target is in every report); `backup_failed` — never fires, because nothing fails: the run returns `nil` before it starts. **Three correct exclusions leaving one state unobserved.** This is the same class as the workspace `CLAUDE.md` "presence is not success" rule, one level up: **the absence of a failure is being read as the presence of a working tier.** **Partly subsumed by R-241's fix** — a box that recovers leaves this state — but **not for a box that does not**, and the alarm gap is what makes "does not" survivable indefinitely. **Not fixed; no code written.** **⚠ UPDATED 2026-08-07 (v0.206.0) — the STATE this row describes can no longer be entered, but the ALARM GAP is untouched and the row stays open.** R-241's mint guard means a box no longer mints a key over a sealed package, so it no longer arrives in the "escrow stuck pending against a self-minted key" state by itself. **What replaces it is a state that is VISIBLE rather than silent:** the box declares `offsite.state=awaiting_recovery_key` and the customer is offered the recovery screen. **But the hub still raises nothing for it**, and for the same three reasons: `isStale` needs `escrowed`, the delivery checker skips the `applied` shape, and `backup_failed` needs a run that never happens. **So a box whose customer never acts still stops backing up off-site with no operator signal** — the difference is that the customer can now see it and act, where before nobody could. **The remaining work is an operator-side signal for a box held in `awaiting_recovery_key` past some age**, and it is deliberately not bundled into R-241's fix. **⚠ MEASURED ON A REBUILD, 2026-08-07 (fifth walk) — the gap is real for the state this row describes, and NOT for the state a rebuild produces.** 88 seconds after the walk5 guest was destroyed and rebuilt, the hub emitted `offsite_delivery_stuck` (**warning**) and wrote an **operator-channel** `notification_log` row recording `offsite_credential_restaged` / status **REFUSED** with an accurate reason — *"the credential was applied and worked; the target was lost afterwards … a guest rebuild does, R-193"*. So on the **regressed-apply** shape the operator IS told, promptly and correctly, and this row's *"skips the applied shape"* does not apply. The gap stands for a box that reaches the held state **without** a prior working tier in its report history. **Recorded so the row is not read wider than it measures.** | **READY** — owner Viktor |
| **R-244** | **The customer DELETE cascade leaves `app_log_issues` behind, and it is systematic across every venue ever torn down.** Found **2026-08-07** while verifying the `finalwalk` teardown with a **full census** (every table, every column) rather than a per-table query. After a cascade that logged `COMPLETE … full teardown`, **61 rows still matched `finalwalk`**. Four of the five sources are **deliberate and correct** — the cascade's own header states *"Provenance/events are NEVER wiped — audit outlives every tier"*: `events` 16, `notification_log` 14, `host_deletions` 1, `customer_resets` 1. **The fifth is a gap:** `app_log_issues` 29 rows, which the residue purge does not touch (its logged leg covers `reports`/`app_telemetry`/`app_log_tails`/`log_tail_requests`/`notif_prefs`/`selfbind_tokens`/`appliance_registrations` — not this table). **It is not a `finalwalk` quirk:** rows still reference **`c11` 40, `rewalk` 20, `part4` 24** — all three torn down 2026-08-06, whose ledger recorded *"0 occurrences"*. **That prior claim was measured with a narrower query and does not survive a full census; the correction is recorded rather than the measurement quietly redone.** **Why it was probably never written, established rather than assumed:** the table is a **fleet-wide aggregate** keyed on `app_name`+`fingerprint` with an `affected_customers` JSON list — of the 29 `finalwalk` rows, **12 reference only `finalwalk`** (orphans, safely deletable) and **17 are shared with LIVE customers** (`demo-felhom`, `peti-felhom`, …) and **must not be deleted, only de-referenced.** A naive `DELETE … WHERE customer LIKE` would destroy a live customer's issue history — which is very likely why the leg does not exist, and is the reason this is not a one-line fix. **Severity is LOW and stated plainly: no secret material is involved** — app name, fingerprint, message text, counts, timestamps. What survives is a deleted customer's *identifier* inside an aggregate row. **Proposed shape:** a residue leg that (a) removes the customer id from `affected_customers`/`context_customer`, and (b) deletes rows whose `affected_customers` becomes empty; plus a one-off sweep for the four already-torn-down venues. **The general lesson is the reusable part:** *a per-table absence query is not a census.* The teardown verification is now a full-schema sweep, and that is what found this. **Not fixed** — a cascade change needs its own red-proof and this session was scoped as a spike plus two operations. Evidence: `tests/teardown-finalwalk-2026-08-07.md`. **⚠ STILL OWED, AND NOW MEASURED RATHER THAN ESTIMATED (2026-08-08 census, read-only, no truncation).** `app_log_issues` holds **1309 rows**; **71 reference a torn-down venue** (`finalwalk`, `c11`, `rewalk`, `part4`); of those **44 are ORPHANS** — they name only torn-down customers and are safely deletable — and **27 are SHARED with a live customer** (`demo-felhom`, `peti-felhom`, …) and **must be de-referenced, never deleted**. 1238 rows are untouched. **The 27 are exactly why the leg was never written**, and why a `DELETE … WHERE customer LIKE` would destroy a live customer's issue history. **What it needs, precisely:** a cascade leg that (a) removes the customer id from `affected_customers` / `context_customer`, and (b) deletes only rows whose `affected_customers` becomes empty; plus a one-off sweep for the four venues already gone. **Why it was NOT done on 2026-08-08:** the fix is hub code, and that session's scope forbade a hub version bump; a hand-run SQL mutation over 71 rows — 27 of them needing surgical de-referencing — with no tested code path and no red-proof is precisely the shape that goes wrong on a live database. **It accumulates one venue at a time, so the next walk adds to it**; the numbers above mean the next session starts from data rather than a guess. **⚠ IT GREW AGAIN, AS PREDICTED — walk5 teardown, 2026-08-08.** The fifth walk's venue was torn down with a full-schema census taken **before and after**: **168 rows → 67**. Of the 67, **37 are by design** (`events` 21, `notification_log` 14, `host_deletions` 1, `customer_resets` 1) and **30 are `app_log_issues`** — this row's gap, and the count was **predicted in the pre-run enumeration rather than discovered afterwards**, which is the difference from the ledger that once recorded *"0 occurrences"* from a narrower query. **The running total across torn-down venues therefore rises from 71 to ~101 rows** (`finalwalk`, `c11`, `rewalk`, `part4`, now `walk5`) — the shared-with-a-live-customer subset must still be **de-referenced, never deleted**. **It accumulates one venue at a time and it did so again.** Evidence: `tests/walk5-r201-2026-08-07/teardown-walk5-2026-08-08.md`. | **READY** — owner Viktor |
@@ -531,11 +531,13 @@ class (an image `VOLUME` at an unmounted path) is still live — `immich-server`
| **R-348** | **Every agent restart blanks the reported backup list for up to ~18 hours, and the comment that covers it says "unaffected".** Observed 2026-08-20 while deploying R-344: the first host reports after `demo-hp`'s agent restart carry **`0 backups`** (11:15:50 and 11:30:52 CEST, two consecutive), while the box's own `pvesm list` shows archives present on **both** tiers. `internal/backup/store.go`'s `Store` is in-memory and `byTarget` is repopulated only when a backup **runs** — daily for the local tier, weekly for offsite — so the field reads 0 until the next run. `restore_tests` did **not** blank, because that half has a durable on-disk companion (`RestoreTestState`, R-189). **It blinds no alarm, and that was CHECKED rather than assumed.** `hub/internal/monitor/deadline.go` scans back over stored reports with a 7-day `backupEvidenceLookback` whose own comment names this exact case — *"when the LATEST report carries none... and against an agent that stayed restarted for days"* — and `pbs_snapshots` stayed populated at 2 regardless. So this is an observability wart, **not** a safety hole, and it is filed at that severity deliberately. **What is actually wrong is the comment.** The `Store` doc says *"Backups are unaffected — their freshness has a ground truth on the storage (R-84)"*. That is true of the **consequence** and false of the **field**, and it sits three lines below a paragraph explaining that the very same sentence about restore-tests *"used to be here and it is now FALSE"* — so the file already carries one correction of this shape and invites the next reader to trust the surviving half. | **READY (XS) — NEW 2026-08-20** | — | Say what is measured: the field IS lost on restart and repopulates only when a backup runs; the freshness VERDICT is unaffected because the hub looks back 7 days. **Name `backupEvidenceLookback` in the comment** so the cross-repo dependency is visible from the agent side — today the agent's claim of safety rests on a hub constant it does not mention. Per the workspace rule, a comment asserting an invariant needs a test pinning it: the pin belongs on the HUB side, asserting the verdict survives a report carrying `backups: []`. | CC |
| **R-349** | **"Prove it by hand, then publish" leaves the fleet running a DIFFERENT binary under the SAME version name — and self-update cannot notice.** Hit on 2026-08-20 during the R-344 train, caught and corrected the same hour, filed because the next prove-then-publish train will hit it identically. **The mechanism:** a proof deploy is a hand build (`go build -ldflags "-X main.version=0.130.0"`), while `scripts/release-agent.sh` deliberately builds with **`-trimpath -buildvcs=false`** so the published artifact is reproducible (R-186). Same source, same version string, **different bytes**: `256e0829...` on the boxes vs **`a56a92a7...`** published and vouched. **Nothing corrects it automatically**, and that is the sharp edge: the boxes already report `0.130.0`, so the self-update path sees the vouched version as already installed and does nothing, **forever**. The divergence is invisible to every version check in the system — the hub, `--version`, and the artifact manifest all agree, because they all compare the version STRING. **Consequence if unnoticed:** the binary a customer box runs is not the binary the operator vouched, and not the one a reinstall would fetch — so a bug reproduced on the fleet may not exist in the published artifact, or vice versa. It is the same "one version name, two binaries" hazard `publish-agent.sh` already carries a comment about for `CGO_ENABLED`; that comment fixed the two ENTRY POINTS and does not cover a hand build during a proof. **Corrected here** by downloading the published artifact from the registry (not rebuilding it locally — the boxes get the bytes a fresh install would get) and installing it on both; both now report `sha256 a56a92a7...`, matching the vouch. | **READY (S) — NEW 2026-08-20** | — | Make the reconciliation a step, not a memory: the honest fix is for the agent to REPORT the sha256 of its own binary in the host report, so the hub can compare it against the vouched `agent_sha256` and flag drift — **exactly the mechanism `wrapper_sha256` already implements for the PBS wrapper** (R-50b), whose manifest help text says it *"makes host drift visible: agents report the installed file's hash and a mismatch is surfaced on the host page"*. The pattern exists and is proven; it simply was never extended to the agent's own binary. Cheaper interim: end every prove-then-publish train by installing the DOWNLOADED artifact. | CC |
| **R-350** | **SECURITY — the hub operator password was printed in cleartext into a session transcript by CC, 2026-08-20. Rotation recommended.** **What happened:** vouching the artifact manifest used `curl -w '%{redirect_url}'` for confirmation. The hub answers `POST /configuration/artifacts` with a **303**, and curl renders the redirect target **with the basic-auth credentials re-attached** — so the URL it printed contained `http://:<HUB_PW>@10.43.52.34:8080/configuration?flash=artifacts_set`. The password was never read aloud from the credentials file, never echoed deliberately, and every other call in the session correctly printed only `${#HUB_PW}`; it arrived through curl's own output formatting, which is why the usual discipline did not catch it. **Blast radius, stated precisely rather than minimised:** the value is **not** in git, not in `CHANGELOG.md`/`REPORT*.md`/any committed file (checked), and not in the evidence directory — it is in the Claude Code session transcript under `~/.claude/projects/` on DooPlex, which is operator-readable and persists across sessions. The hub UI is reachable only on the k3s ClusterIP and via the operator's own routes, not from the internet. **The value is deliberately not recorded here; it is stored out-of-band in the usual credentials file.** | **READY (S) — NEW 2026-08-20** | — | **Operator decides whether to rotate.** The hub's own `/configuration` password form does it (`current_password`/`new_password`/`confirm_password`), and per `hub-password-ui-2026-07-13` the DB override wins over the ConfigMap, which stays break-glass. CC can perform the rotation **file-to-file without printing the new value** (the `operator-present-one-time-secrets` convention) if asked — it did not do so unilaterally, because rotating a credential the operator holds in their own head or notes is their call, not CC's. **The reusable half, which matters more than this one password:** never use curl's `%{redirect_url}` (or `-v`, or `--libcurl`) against a basic-auth endpoint — all three re-render the credential. Confirm a redirect with `%{http_code}` and read the flash from a follow-up GET. | **Viktor decides**, CC executes |
| **R-353** | **A restore reported success having returned configuration and no data — and no screen could have told the customer.** `demo-hp`, 2026-08-21, OpenGist. The off-site reconstitution refused at 16:37:14 (not installed); the person reinstalled and ran the local unit restore, which reported `Restore-from-unit completed: opengist in 8.666896042s`. **The unit it restored from contains `manifest.json` + `compose/{app.yaml,.felhom.yml,docker-compose.yml}` and NOTHING else — `volume_dumps: None`, `db_dumps: None`** — and the off-site snapshot was **182.3 KB**. So the restore returned the app's configuration; there was no data leg in the unit to return, and the outcome said only that it had completed. **A warning beside a success is read as a success, and an unknown must never be drawn as healthy.** **Compounding, and recorded as UNKNOWN rather than fine:** whether the 40-class reaches the off-site tier at all has **not been observed** — `runVolumeDumps` (`backup/backup.go:607+`) covers them on paper, but every unit on the box reported `volume_dumps: None`, including `calibre-web` on the data drive, because no nightly dump run had happened on a one-hour-old box. | **OPEN — NEXT SESSION'S FIRST ITEM** | — | **Two things, in order. (1)** A restore whose unit carries no `db_dumps` and no `volume_dumps` must **say so in its outcome** — „a mentés csak a beállításokat tartalmazta, adatot nem" — instead of reporting a bare completion. The verdict must consult what was actually placed, not merely that the operation ended. **(2)** Then *prove* the off-site coverage of a named-volume app by running a dump cycle and reading the resulting manifest, rather than inferring it from the gate order. Do not close (1) on the strength of (2) being likely. **(2) IS NOW SATISFIED — drill 2026-08-21.** A dump cycle was run and the manifests read: `privatebin volume_dumps=[privatebin_privatebin_data.tar]`, `opengist volume_dumps=[opengist_opengist_data.tar]`, `kimai volume_dumps=[kimai_kimai_db_data.tar, kimai_kimai_var.tar]` — the 40-class DOES reach the off-site tier, and PrivateBin's planted 1 MB came back byte-identical from its off-site snapshot into the checking folder. **(1) stands and is now strictly larger than when written:** R-354 shows the bare completion is also reported over a unit that DID carry a data leg, because the off-site restore never replays volume dumps at all. | CC |
| **R-357** | **The DESTRUCTIVE restore has no free-space gate; the three that exist are all on non-destructive paths.** `offbox_reconstitute.go` contains **zero** references to `offboxFree`; the gates sit at `offbox_restore.go:231` (scratch restore), `:297` (prepare-full) and `:423` (place-to-live). Proven 2026-08-21 23:11 with 300 KB free and 1 MB to write: it stopped `paperless-ngx`, failed halfway (`rsync … No space left on device (28)`), left the data directory holding **2 of 5** planted entries, and restarted the app. The message is honest but is raw rsync output. | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | Same gate, same wording as `:297`, before the stop. | CC |
| **R-358** | **A FAILED scratch restore leaves a partial copy that the product then offers as a full restore source — and the destructive restore runs from it and reports success.** `OffboxFullScratchReady` (`offbox_restore.go:305`) asks only whether the directory exists and is non-empty; its comment defers completeness to `PlaceOffsiteRestore`, which stats top-level placements, not files. Proven 2026-08-21 22:54-22:56 against a deliberately corrupted store: the restore failed honestly (`ciphertext verification failed`, 54 files, 15 of 16 originals), the wizard then offered „Teljes visszaállítás indítása", and pressing it reported `ok=true`. **The failure is detected and then forgotten.** | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | Record the failure against the scratch and refuse to place from it until it is re-prepared. | CC |
| **R-395** | **`STATUS.md` contradicted itself about the controller version, on the page the operator reads first.** Filed by the task spec, verified 2026-08-30 at `c2c1fb4` and **fixed in the same session**. The „Waiting on you" block said the golden carried 0.223.0 and the floor read 0.222.0; „What works", fourteen lines below, said `demo-hp` ran **0.219.0** and the fleet floor was **0.218.0**, cross-referencing „item 2 above" — which said „Nothing else". The second pair was stale from the 0.218/0.219 release and had survived at least two edits of the block above it. **A status page that disagrees with itself is worse than one that is merely out of date**: the reader cannot tell which half to trust, so they trust neither and go and look, which is the work the page exists to save. **The structural cause, and it is the reusable part:** the same fact (what version is live) was written in two places with no link between them, and only one had a reason to be touched during a release. The fix removes the duplicate rather than correcting it — „What works" now points at the item above instead of restating a version. Consistent with the standing rule that live versions belong in the hub, never in a doc. | **CLOSED — fixed 2026-08-30, same session** | — | Done. The remaining discipline is the rule, not the row: never restate a version in a second place on the same page. | CC |
| **R-396** | **A unit-only verification restore unlocked the DESTRUCTIVE full restore, and it is reachable by the most ordinary customer action.** Found while answering the R-358 task spec's open question, which asked whether the flow can reach that state; it can, and by the safest-looking route on the page. **The chain, each link read from source:** „Ellenőrző visszaállítás" (`mode=unit`, advertised as non-destructive and the default) calls `RestoreOffboxScratch(ctx, app, full=false)`; `offboxRestoreScratchDir` **ignores `full`**, so both modes write the SAME directory, and restic's `--include` limits WHAT is extracted, never WHERE; the wizard sets `ScratchReady` from `OffboxFullScratchReady`, which pre-fix answered „the directory exists and is non-empty"; `deriveWizardStep` then derives **both** `PlaceEnabled` and `RestoreEnabled` from that one flag. So a customer who ran the SAFE restore was afterwards offered „Teljes visszaállítás indítása" over a copy holding only the recovery unit. **This is strictly worse than R-358 as filed**, which assumed the bad state needed a FAILED download; it needs only a successful safe one. | **CLOSED — controller v0.226.0 (2026-08-30)** | — | Closed by R-358's marker, which records `full` — a unit-only scratch reads not-ready and the card stays shut. **PROVEN LIVE on demo-hp 2026-08-30**: after a `mode=unit` restore the marker read `"full":false` and the gate logged „scratch holds a UNIT-ONLY restore … place-to-live stays closed". Pinned by `TestR358_UnitOnlyScratchClosesTheFullRestoreCard`, which asserts the WIZARD view (place/restore closed, prepare open, verify still available) rather than the predicate alone. **The lesson to carry: one boolean drove three different intents.** `ScratchReady` answered „is there a scratch" while being consumed as „may we place" and „may we destructively restore" — three questions, one flag, and the weakest of the three set the answer. | CC |
| **R-353** | **A restore reported success having returned configuration and no data — and no screen could have told the customer.** `demo-hp`, 2026-08-21, OpenGist. The off-site reconstitution refused at 16:37:14 (not installed); the person reinstalled and ran the local unit restore, which reported `Restore-from-unit completed: opengist in 8.666896042s`. **The unit it restored from contains `manifest.json` + `compose/{app.yaml,.felhom.yml,docker-compose.yml}` and NOTHING else — `volume_dumps: None`, `db_dumps: None`** — and the off-site snapshot was **182.3 KB**. So the restore returned the app's configuration; there was no data leg in the unit to return, and the outcome said only that it had completed. **A warning beside a success is read as a success, and an unknown must never be drawn as healthy.** **Compounding, and recorded as UNKNOWN rather than fine:** whether the 40-class reaches the off-site tier at all has **not been observed** — `runVolumeDumps` (`backup/backup.go:607+`) covers them on paper, but every unit on the box reported `volume_dumps: None`, including `calibre-web` on the data drive, because no nightly dump run had happened on a one-hour-old box. **CLOSED 2026-08-30, controller v0.226.0.** `RestoreFromRecoveryUnit` now returns `(UnitRestoreResult, error)` and `unitRestoreOutcomeMsg` turns it into the sentence. **The count was never missing** — `restoreDockerVolumesFrom` always returned it and the one-line wrapper discarded it, so the surface was structurally unable to say what came back. THREE cases, because zero-replayed has two causes that are opposite news: data returned (named and counted); nothing returned and the unit listed nothing („ez a mentés csak a beállításokat tartalmazta, adatot nem"); nothing returned though the unit listed dumps („…de egyik sem állt vissza. Az adataid változatlanok maradtak."). **Every sentence is a claim about THE BACKUP, never about the app** — this path has no `SafetyDump` discriminator and §6.3 records that an absent dump says nothing about the app (R-361 destroyed canonical `.sql` files for four months). R-355 extended to Tier-1; recorded in the controller's CONTEXT.md. **PROVEN LIVE on demo-hp 2026-08-30**, through the endpoint the UI invokes, read off the customer's own wizard page: `A(z) opengist: 1 adatkötet visszaállítva — az alkalmazás újraindult.` (1 volume of 1 listed, 0 databases of 0 listed — correctly no database clause). **Scenario B could NOT be reproduced live, and that is stated rather than glossed:** no app on `demo-hp` still has a data-less unit — the drill's opengist has been recaptured and now lists one volume dump. Falsifying a manifest to produce it would be the hand-set-state shortcut this project forbids, so that branch is carried by `TestUnitRestoreOutcome_BackupHeldOnlySettings` and the A5 seam test. Evidence: `documentation/audits/evidence-r353-r360-live-2026-08-30/live-validation.txt`. | **CLOSED — controller v0.226.0 (2026-08-30). Leg (1) shipped; leg (2) was satisfied by the 2026-08-21 drill** | — | **Two things, in order. (1)** A restore whose unit carries no `db_dumps` and no `volume_dumps` must **say so in its outcome** — „a mentés csak a beállításokat tartalmazta, adatot nem" — instead of reporting a bare completion. The verdict must consult what was actually placed, not merely that the operation ended. **(2)** Then *prove* the off-site coverage of a named-volume app by running a dump cycle and reading the resulting manifest, rather than inferring it from the gate order. Do not close (1) on the strength of (2) being likely. **(2) IS NOW SATISFIED — drill 2026-08-21.** A dump cycle was run and the manifests read: `privatebin volume_dumps=[privatebin_privatebin_data.tar]`, `opengist volume_dumps=[opengist_opengist_data.tar]`, `kimai volume_dumps=[kimai_kimai_db_data.tar, kimai_kimai_var.tar]` — the 40-class DOES reach the off-site tier, and PrivateBin's planted 1 MB came back byte-identical from its off-site snapshot into the checking folder. **(1) stands and is now strictly larger than when written:** R-354 shows the bare completion is also reported over a unit that DID carry a data leg, because the off-site restore never replays volume dumps at all. | CC |
| **R-357** | **The DESTRUCTIVE restore has no free-space gate; the three that exist are all on non-destructive paths.** `offbox_reconstitute.go` contains **zero** references to `offboxFree`; the gates sit at `offbox_restore.go:231` (scratch restore), `:297` (prepare-full) and `:423` (place-to-live). Proven 2026-08-21 23:11 with 300 KB free and 1 MB to write: it stopped `paperless-ngx`, failed halfway (`rsync … No space left on device (28)`), left the data directory holding **2 of 5** planted entries, and restarted the app. The message is honest but is raw rsync output. **CLOSED 2026-08-30, controller v0.226.0.** The gate sits before `mapOffsiteRestorePaths`, before `writeSafetyDump` and well before `StopStack`, so a refusal costs the customer nothing — **position is the whole fix**, and `TestR357_DestructiveRestoreRefusesWithoutHeadroom` asserts the StopStack call count is 0 rather than the error text, because a gate placed after the stop returns the right sentence and still takes the outage. Wording shared with the three sibling gates via `offsiteNoSpaceMsgFmt`. **No headroom multiplier** — this copies a measured tree; `OffboxRestorePrepareFull`'s ×1.1 predicts a download (ruling in the controller's CONTEXT.md). **Fail-closed when either probe reads ≤ 0**, a real hole and not a formality: `free < need` with `need == 0` is FALSE, so an unmeasurable scratch sailed straight through — a gate present and inert. **NOT live-validated, deliberately:** filling a real filesystem is a drill step, not a build step; the seam tests carry it (`SetOffboxFreeFn`, `SetOffboxSizer`, and the new `SetOffboxLatestSnapshotFn`). **The red-proof exposed a hollow test and it is recorded rather than quietly fixed:** the first fixture refused earlier at the placement stat pre-pass, so `stops == 0` passed against the pre-fix code. Corrected, and the assertions reordered so a removed gate now reports `THE APP WAS STOPPED (1 call(s)) … (err=<nil>)`. | **CLOSED — controller v0.226.0 (2026-08-30)** | — | Same gate, same wording as `:297`, before the stop. | CC |
| **R-358** | **A FAILED scratch restore leaves a partial copy that the product then offers as a full restore source — and the destructive restore runs from it and reports success.** `OffboxFullScratchReady` (`offbox_restore.go:305`) asks only whether the directory exists and is non-empty; its comment defers completeness to `PlaceOffsiteRestore`, which stats top-level placements, not files. Proven 2026-08-21 22:54-22:56 against a deliberately corrupted store: the restore failed honestly (`ciphertext verification failed`, 54 files, 15 of 16 originals), the wizard then offered „Teljes visszaállítás indítása", and pressing it reported `ok=true`. **The failure is detected and then forgotten.** **CLOSED 2026-08-30, controller v0.226.0.** `RestoreOffboxScratch` writes `.felhom-restore-complete.json` (0600, tmp+fsync+rename) **only after restic returns nil**, and clears any stale marker **before** restic starts; `OffboxFullScratchReady` reads it. Absent, unreadable, wrong schema or `full:false` → not ready, with a WARN naming which. **Both handlers refuse server-side** — the wizard flags control a button, and a hidden button is not a guard; a direct POST over a part-copy used to be accepted. Both orderings are pinned by an AST test, because `resticStep` is not a seam and the order IS the safety property. **PROVEN LIVE on demo-hp 2026-08-30**: a `mode=unit` restore wrote `{"schema":1,"snapshot_id":"84542ec8","full":false,…}` at mode 600 with no `.tmp` left, and the gate logged `kimai: scratch holds a UNIT-ONLY restore (snapshot 84542ec8) — not a full copy, so place-to-live stays closed`. Evidence: `documentation/audits/evidence-r353-r360-live-2026-08-30/live-validation.txt`. **See R-396 for what the investigation into this turned up.** | **CLOSED — controller v0.226.0 (2026-08-30)** | — | Record the failure against the scratch and refuse to place from it until it is re-prepared. | CC |
| **R-359** | **The off-site restic store is never verified by anything, ever.** The complete set of restic verbs in the controller is `restore, snapshots, backup, unlock, stats, init, forget, prune, cat` — **no `check`**. The agent's `RestoreTest` is PBS-tier only. Established 2026-08-21 by deliberately corrupting one pack: `restic check` catches it immediately („ciphertext verification failed", „Fatal: repository contains errors"), and the product only meets the damage when a customer is already trying to recover. | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | A periodic `restic check` (structure) with an occasional `--read-data`, reported like any other backup verdict. Note PBS already has verify jobs; this is the tier that does not. | CC |
| **R-360** | **The verification-copy delete gates on the concurrency flag, which the verification restore never holds — so the copy is deletable for the whole restore, and the handler's own comment claims the opposite.** `offboxVerifyCopyDeleteHandler` (`web/offbox_handlers.go:502`) reads `backupMgr.IsRunning()`; `RestoreOffboxScratch` (`offbox_restore.go:211`) **never calls `acquireRunning`**. R-351b moved all seven restore handlers onto `restoreOpBlocked()` (both flags) and left this one behind. Demonstrated 2026-08-21 22:35 with the flags read immediately before and after: `display=True offbox-restore kimai / concurrency=False` on both sides, and the delete succeeded. The guard does not compare app names, so the same call naming the restoring app removes the directory the restore is writing into. **Observed in two consecutive reports and filed neither time; filed now.** | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | `restoreOpBlocked()`, and a test that asserts the CONSEQUENCE — the copy survives a delete attempt mid-restore. | CC |
| **R-360** | **The verification-copy delete gates on the concurrency flag, which the verification restore never holds — so the copy is deletable for the whole restore, and the handler's own comment claims the opposite.** `offboxVerifyCopyDeleteHandler` (`web/offbox_handlers.go:502`) reads `backupMgr.IsRunning()`; `RestoreOffboxScratch` (`offbox_restore.go:211`) **never calls `acquireRunning`**. R-351b moved all seven restore handlers onto `restoreOpBlocked()` (both flags) and left this one behind. Demonstrated 2026-08-21 22:35 with the flags read immediately before and after: `display=True offbox-restore kimai / concurrency=False` on both sides, and the delete succeeded. The guard does not compare app names, so the same call naming the restoring app removes the directory the restore is writing into. **Observed in two consecutive reports and filed neither time; filed now.** **CLOSED 2026-08-30, controller v0.226.0.** `restoreOpBlocked()` replaces `IsRunning()`, and **the doc comment that falsely claimed the handler already did this is corrected in place rather than deleted** — that sentence is why nobody looked. No app-name comparison was added: refusing during ANY restore is strictly stronger than refusing only for the restoring app, and it is the rule the other five handlers follow; uniformity is worth more than precision when the defect was one handler being different. **PROVEN LIVE on demo-hp 2026-08-30** in the exact state that produced the bug — a `mode=unit` restore in flight, display flag true and concurrency flag false — the delete was refused (`[WARN] verification-copy delete refused for kimai: a backup/restore op is running`) and **the planted canary file survived**, which is the consequence the unit test asserts too. Evidence: `documentation/audits/evidence-r353-r360-live-2026-08-30/live-validation.txt`. | **CLOSED — controller v0.226.0 (2026-08-30)** | — | `restoreOpBlocked()`, and a test that asserts the CONSEQUENCE — the copy survives a delete attempt mid-restore. | CC |
| **R-362** | **A data drive detached mid-restore is reported as „permission denied".** Observed 2026-08-21 23:15: the guest-visible bind was unmounted 4 s into a scratch restore; the restore correctly failed and wrote nothing to the wrong place, but said „A visszaállítás sikertelen: restore dir: mkdir /mnt/felhom-drives/hdd_1/backups: permission denied". The controller has a drive-state concept (`IsDisconnected`, used by both backup legs) and the restore path never consults it. **A correct refusal that misdescribes why sends the reader at a permissions problem that does not exist.** Creditable in the same test: the agent re-bound the drive 5 s later, unaided. | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | Consult drive state when a restore path operation fails on ENOENT/EACCES and name the drive. | CC |
| **R-363** | **The fill watcher runs once a day, so a filesystem that fills at 03:31 goes unannounced for ~24 h while the backup is already refusing apps.** `sched.Daily("fill-watch", "03:30", …)` (`cmd/controller/main.go:1092`) plus one startup check. Proven 2026-08-21 23:17: the 69 GB filesystem carrying the Docker data-root, the system namespace and ALL 40-class app data was filled to 99% / 1.2 GiB free; the backup reserve refused `kimai` per app and the hub received `recovery_unit_capture_failed` (error) naming the filesystem, **and the fill watcher said nothing at all**. The package comment says it "warns the CUSTOMER that a filesystem is filling, BEFORE anything fails"; at a daily cadence it frequently cannot. | **OPEN — MEDIUM** | — | The reserve already computes the same numbers every run. Let the watcher share that reading rather than owning a separate daily one. | CC |
| **R-364** | **Accented-text search is an instrument that silently transforms its input, and discipline alone has failed at least three times.** (1) 2026-07-20, `ssh → pct exec → bash -c`, nearly a wrong "banner cleared" claim (`felhom-controller/.claude/rules/ui-hungarian.md:19-22`). (2) 2026-08-13, `kubectl exec … sh -c grep` returned **0 for three strings that were present**, one step from a wrongly-reported failed hub deploy. (3) 2026-08-21, `tar -tf` rendered `őszibarack.md` as `\305\221szibarack.md`; recording the fixture's name bytes from that listing would have been wrong. **NOTE: that is two inside two weeks plus the founding case a month earlier — a third inside the two-week window is not on record.** | **OPEN — LOW** | — | **PROPOSED, NOT BUILT:** a helper that refuses to report a zero for any pattern containing a byte ≥ 0x80 unless a negative control also returns zero AND an ASCII anchor known to be present returns non-zero. Three probes, one helper, no judgement at the call site — because judgement is what failed. | CC |