Four defects on the restore surface, all proven on demo-hp during the 2026-08-21
backup-truth drill, all still in shipped code. They share one acceptance idea: a
restore surface must state what it actually did, and must refuse what it cannot
do.
VERSION NOTE. The task specifying this targeted v0.224.0 against baseline
f8c9390. Both were consumed earlier the same day by R-330 (0.224.0) and R-331
(0.225.0). Drift re-confirmed against live Gitea before the first edit, operator
authorised proceeding, every symbol the spec named re-verified present at the
real baseline e5eee50.
R-353 -- a restore that gave back nothing still said it worked.
RestoreFromRecoveryUnit returned only error, so the surface printed
"<app> visszaallitva (<snapshot>)." -- equally true of a run that returned an
entire dataset and one that returned nothing. The count already existed and was
discarded one line deep: restoreDockerVolumesFrom always returned it, the
wrapper threw it away. Now (UnitRestoreResult, error), carrying replayed counts
AND what the manifest LISTED, because zero-replayed has two causes that are
opposite news. Three cases, three sentences, and EVERY one is a claim about the
BACKUP, never about the app -- this path has no SafetyDump discriminator, and
07-backup-architecture 6.3 records that an absent dump says nothing about the
app (R-361 destroyed canonical .sql files for four months).
R-357 -- the destructive restore had no free-space gate. offbox_reconstitute.go
contained ZERO references to offboxFree; all three existing gates guard
non-destructive paths. The gate now sits before mapOffsiteRestorePaths,
writeSafetyDump and StopStack, so a refusal costs nothing. Position IS the fix,
which is why the test asserts StopStack was never called. No headroom multiplier
(matches PlaceOffsiteRestore; the x1.1 elsewhere predicts a download). Fail
closed on either probe <= 0 -- otherwise `free < need` with need==0 is FALSE and
an unmeasurable scratch sails through: a gate present and inert.
R-358 -- a failed download was offered as a good one. The gate answered "the
directory exists and is non-empty", which is exactly what a part-way restic run
leaves. Now a completion marker written 0600 atomically AFTER restic returns
nil, with any stale one cleared BEFORE it starts; both orders pinned by an AST
test because resticStep is not a seam. Both handlers refuse server-side: the
wizard flags control a button, and a hidden button is not a guard.
SCENARIO F ANSWERED, and worse than the question assumed: a unit-only scratch IS
reachable through the real flow, by the most ordinary route. "Ellenorzo
visszaallitas" (mode=unit, advertised non-destructive) writes the SAME directory
-- offboxRestoreScratchDir ignores `full` and --include limits what restic
extracts, never where -- so a customer who ran the SAFE restore was then offered
the destructive one over a unit-only copy. Filed R-396; the marker closes it.
R-360 -- the delete refused only while a BACKUP ran. IsRunning() is FALSE for the
whole of a verification restore; the five sibling handlers all use
restoreOpBlocked(). Its doc comment claimed it already did this, which is why
nobody looked -- corrected in place.
Red-proofs, each printing the pre-fix behaviour, in CHANGELOG and REPORT. The
first R-357 red-proof exposed a hollow test OF MY OWN and it is recorded rather
than quietly fixed: the fixture refused earlier at the placement stat pre-pass,
so `stops == 0` passed against the pre-fix code. Fixture corrected, assertions
reordered so a removed gate reports the outage rather than "no error returned".
Green gate clean: 28 packages, rc 0. All 12 controller gates OK.
The recovery unit on the customer's drive now carries the PORTABLE secret
class, so Tier-1/Tier-2 restore no longer depends on the whole-guest tier.
A customer needs the drive and nothing else.
Part 0's rulings overturned the brief's recommendation, on evidence:
- the data_key flag is untrustworthy (4+ encryption keys the catalog itself
labels as such are unflagged) -> R-127
- a DB password is not resettable in practice: POSTGRES_PASSWORD is ignored
once PGDATA is non-empty, so a regenerated value leaves the app unable to
authenticate against its own restored rows while the dump replay still
reports success (proven on a throwaway postgres:16-alpine)
Ruling (operator): type:secret travels, type:password never does, minus the
nonPortableSecrets code register. Plaintext -- withholding the internet-
reachable class is what licenses that, and the two are coupled.
Precedence: the UNIT WINS over the guest -- the unit's secrets were captured
in the same run as the dumps beside them, so they match the data being
restored. The fail-closed data-key gate is unchanged.
Secret values are never logged; the manifest records NAMES only.
Adds an in-process orchestration test for RestoreFromRecoveryUnit: success path
calls recreate with non-secret env + recovered secrets merged; data-key-missing
path is REFUSED and recreate is never called. Makes Manager.isDebug nil-safe
(behavior-neutral in prod; cfg is always set) so the gate/orchestration are testable.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Restore recreates an app from its on-drive unit + the guest's own secrets,
regenerating nothing. reconcileRestoreSecrets (pure, unit-tested) merges the unit's
non-secret env with secrets recovered from the live app.yaml and FAILS CLOSED if a
data-encrypting key is unrecoverable (refuse — a PBS whole-guest restore is needed —
rather than regenerate and corrupt). Resettable secrets missing → warn + proceed.
- backup: RestoreFromRecoveryUnit (manifest -> recover secrets -> gate -> restore
volumes -> recreate definition + redeploy w/ re-pull); falls back to volume-only.
- seams: RecoverStackSecrets/RecreateStackFromUnit (adapter +encKey),
stacks.RedeployFromEnv. Wired into /backup/restore.
- tests: gate (refuse/proceed/verbatim) + data_key parsing.
Gate + reconcile + data_key parsing unit-tested; capture live-validated (v0.53.1).
Full readable-data e2e vs AdventureLog needs the auth-gated dashboard restore — pending.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
admin