Files
felhom-agent/internal/localapi/guestpower.go
T
admin 367a503a0f F-REBOOT + F-LEAK: the agent's authority over guest lifecycle (v0.107.0)
F-REBOOT — a guest rebooted mid-backup never came back (fault 11: 9m47s of total
appliance outage, no lock, nothing retrying). The existing stale-lock recovery is
correct but missed it two ways: its predicate needs a stale vzdump lock and that
guest was unlocked, and it runs only at agent startup. New periodic guest-power
watchdog acts on 'should be running, is not, is not locked'.

onboot is the should-be-running signal, not invented here: stalelock.go already
uses it for this same decision, it is 0 on scratch/golden, and pve-guests uses it
at host boot. Guards: onboot:0 never touched (Scenario B), a locked guest is left
to the stale-lock path, a guest with a vzdump in flight is left stopped,
unprovable ownership acts on nothing, unconfirmable backup state fails safe.
Bounded retry 3x at 1/2/4m then ERROR (Scenario C) — a healthy start takes ~25s.

F-LEAK — a failed restore-test could not destroy its scratch (403 VM.Allocate).
It is pool membership, not privsep: VM.Allocate is granted at /pool/felhom only,
and a failed restore never completes the --pool association. Fix needs NO new
grant — Pool.Allocate is already held, so the teardown adopts the stranded
scratch into the pool and retries the destroy. Guarded by scratchAdoptAllowed:
scratch provenance AND the numeric band, both required (Scenario E).

Six red-proofs across both fixes, all observed failing.
2026-07-28 10:27:07 +02:00

239 lines
9.5 KiB
Go

package localapi
import (
"context"
"sync"
"time"
"gitea.dooplex.hu/admin/felhom-agent/internal/proxmox"
)
// F-REBOOT (Campaign 8 fault 11) — a guest that should be running and is not.
//
// THE OUTAGE THIS EXISTS TO KILL. A `pct reboot` issued while a vzdump was in flight completed its
// SHUTDOWN half and never issued the start. The guest was found `stopped` with 0 containers, no
// lock, and nothing retrying; it stayed down 9m47s until a human ran `pct start`. The backup itself
// SUCCEEDED — so every alarm the appliance has was silent, because nothing was broken except that
// the customer's entire appliance was off.
//
// WHY THE EXISTING RECOVERY MISSED IT. `RecoverStaleLockedGuests` (stalelock.go) already does
// unlock → delete dangling snapshot → start iff onboot, and it is CORRECT. It missed this by two
// gaps, both narrow:
// - its predicate acts only on a guest holding a stale vzdump lock (`backup`/`snapshot-delete`);
// fault 11's guest was stopped and UNLOCKED, so it returned early;
// - it runs ONCE at agent startup, on the load-bearing invariant that a backup lock present then
// is stale by definition. A guest that goes down while the agent is already up is never
// re-examined.
//
// This watchdog closes exactly those two gaps and nothing more: it is periodic, and it acts on
// "should be running, is not, and is not locked".
//
// ── THE TRAP, WHICH IS THE SAME SHAPE AS F-CRIT-1's ──────────────────────────────────────────
//
// A guest the operator deliberately stopped must NOT be auto-started. Fighting the operator makes
// maintenance impossible and is worse than the outage — the same over-correction that F-CRIT-1's fix
// had to avoid when it stopped whitelisting StateStopped.
//
// The distinction used is `onboot`, and it is deliberately NOT invented here:
// - it is ALREADY the distinction stalelock.go uses for exactly this decision
// (`if onboot && g.Status != "running"`), so the two paths cannot disagree;
// - it is 1 on customer guests and 0 on scratch/golden guests (agent v0.101.0 sets scratch to 0);
// - it is the same flag `pve-guests` itself consults at host boot, so the agent AGREES WITH THE
// PLATFORM rather than maintaining a second, private definition of "should be running".
//
// The hub's desired-state `Run` (internal/desired) is a stronger signal and is wired, but it is
// hub-dependent. `onboot` keeps working on a box that has lost hub contact — which is precisely when
// an unattended appliance most needs to come back up.
const (
// guestPowerInterval is how often the watchdog looks. Matches the guestnet watchdog's cadence so
// the two guest-facing sweeps stay in step, and is far below the 9m47s outage the finding recorded.
guestPowerInterval = 60 * time.Second
// guestPowerMaxAttempts bounds the retry. A guest that will not start must not be started in a
// loop forever (Scenario C) — after this many failures the watchdog stops trying and raises it.
guestPowerMaxAttempts = 3
)
// guestPowerBackoff is the delay before each retry: 1m, 2m, 4m.
//
// Measured, not picked round: a healthy `pct start` of guest 9201 completed in ~25 s (observed twice
// on 2026-07-28), so even the first 1-minute wait carries 2.4x headroom over a normal start. Three
// attempts bound the disruption at roughly 7 minutes — inside the 9m47s outage this fixes — while
// never becoming an unbounded loop.
var guestPowerBackoff = []time.Duration{time.Minute, 2 * time.Minute, 4 * time.Minute}
// guestPowerState is one guest's recovery attempt record. In-memory on purpose, like the R-88
// breaker: an agent restart re-attempts immediately, which is the cheap direction to fail — a
// forgotten backoff costs one extra start attempt, whereas persisting it could carry a stale
// "this guest won't start" verdict across the restart that fixed it.
type guestPowerState struct {
attempts int
nextAt time.Time
raised bool // the give-up fault has already been raised for this run
}
// WatchGuestPower runs the guest-power sweep every guestPowerInterval until ctx is done. No-op when
// the stale-lock controller is not wired (it supplies the ownership-proven guest list).
func (s *Server) WatchGuestPower(ctx context.Context) {
if s.staleLock == nil {
return
}
s.logger.Info("guest-power: watchdog started", "interval", guestPowerInterval.String(),
"max_attempts", guestPowerMaxAttempts)
t := time.NewTicker(guestPowerInterval)
defer t.Stop()
for {
select {
case <-ctx.Done():
return
case <-t.C:
s.GuestPowerTick(ctx)
}
}
}
// GuestPowerTick performs one sweep. Exported so a test (and a live check) can drive exactly one
// cycle instead of waiting on the ticker.
func (s *Server) GuestPowerTick(ctx context.Context) {
if s.staleLock == nil {
return
}
guests, err := s.staleLock.Guests(ctx)
if err != nil {
// Unknown ownership ⇒ do nothing. Never fall back to an unfiltered list: starting a
// co-tenant's guest would be worse than leaving ours down.
s.logger.Warn("guest-power: guest list unavailable — skipping sweep (ownership unproven)", "err", err)
return
}
for _, g := range guests {
if ctx.Err() != nil {
return
}
s.recoverOneStoppedGuest(ctx, g)
}
}
// recoverOneStoppedGuest starts a single guest that should be running and is not.
func (s *Server) recoverOneStoppedGuest(ctx context.Context, g proxmox.Guest) {
if g.Status == "running" {
s.forgetGuestPower(g.VMID) // healthy again: clear any attempt history
return
}
lock, onboot, err := s.staleLock.Lock(ctx, g.VMID)
if err != nil {
s.logger.Warn("guest-power: read guest config failed — skipping", "vmid", g.VMID, "err", err)
return
}
// SCENARIO B — a deliberately stopped guest is left alone, forever. onboot:0 means the operator
// (or the golden-image provisioning) does not want this guest running.
if !onboot {
return
}
// A locked guest belongs to another operation, mid-flight or stale. The stale-lock recovery owns
// that case and knows how to prove a lock is stale; this watchdog must not race it or start a
// guest whose lock means "a restore is writing my disks right now".
if lock != "" {
s.logger.Info("guest-power: guest is stopped but LOCKED — leaving it to the stale-lock path",
"vmid", g.VMID, "lock", lock)
return
}
// Never start a guest while a vzdump is genuinely in flight for it — a stop-mode backup stops the
// guest ON PURPOSE and starting it underneath would corrupt the backup. Fail safe on doubt.
running, err := s.staleLock.BackupRunning(ctx, g.VMID)
if err != nil {
s.logger.Warn("guest-power: could not confirm no backup is running — NOT starting (fail-safe)",
"vmid", g.VMID, "err", err)
return
}
if running {
s.logger.Info("guest-power: a vzdump is in flight — leaving the guest stopped until it finishes",
"vmid", g.VMID)
return
}
st, due := s.guestPowerDue(g.VMID)
if !due {
return
}
if st.attempts >= guestPowerMaxAttempts {
// SCENARIO C — bounded. Raise it ONCE and stop retrying; an infinite silent retry loop is the
// over-correction here, and a guest that has refused three starts needs a human, not a fourth.
if !st.raised {
s.markGuestPowerRaised(g.VMID)
s.logger.Error("guest-power: GIVING UP — guest should be running (onboot) but failed to start after repeated attempts; it needs operator attention",
"vmid", g.VMID, "attempts", st.attempts, "status", g.Status)
}
return
}
s.logger.Warn("guest-power: guest should be running (onboot) but is stopped and unlocked — starting it",
"vmid", g.VMID, "status", g.Status, "attempt", st.attempts+1, "of", guestPowerMaxAttempts)
if err := s.staleLock.Start(ctx, g.VMID); err != nil {
s.noteGuestPowerFailure(g.VMID)
s.logger.Error("guest-power: start failed", "vmid", g.VMID, "attempt", st.attempts+1, "err", err)
return
}
s.forgetGuestPower(g.VMID)
s.logger.Warn("guest-power: STARTED a guest that should have been running", "vmid", g.VMID)
}
// ---- attempt bookkeeping (guarded by its own mutex; independent of the jobs lock) ----------
var guestPowerMu sync.Mutex
// guestPowerDue reports the guest's attempt state and whether a new attempt is due now.
func (s *Server) guestPowerDue(vmid int) (guestPowerState, bool) {
guestPowerMu.Lock()
defer guestPowerMu.Unlock()
if s.guestPower == nil {
s.guestPower = map[int]guestPowerState{}
}
st := s.guestPower[vmid]
if st.nextAt.IsZero() || !s.now().Before(st.nextAt) {
return st, true
}
return st, false
}
// noteGuestPowerFailure records a failed start and arms the next backoff.
func (s *Server) noteGuestPowerFailure(vmid int) {
guestPowerMu.Lock()
defer guestPowerMu.Unlock()
if s.guestPower == nil {
s.guestPower = map[int]guestPowerState{}
}
st := s.guestPower[vmid]
st.attempts++
i := st.attempts - 1
if i >= len(guestPowerBackoff) {
i = len(guestPowerBackoff) - 1
}
st.nextAt = s.now().Add(guestPowerBackoff[i])
s.guestPower[vmid] = st
}
// markGuestPowerRaised records that the give-up fault has been raised, so it is logged once.
func (s *Server) markGuestPowerRaised(vmid int) {
guestPowerMu.Lock()
defer guestPowerMu.Unlock()
st := s.guestPower[vmid]
st.raised = true
s.guestPower[vmid] = st
}
// forgetGuestPower clears a guest's attempt history — called when it is running again, so a guest
// that recovers does not carry its old failures into the next incident.
func (s *Server) forgetGuestPower(vmid int) {
guestPowerMu.Lock()
defer guestPowerMu.Unlock()
if s.guestPower == nil {
return
}
delete(s.guestPower, vmid)
}